A comprehensive analysis of the vietnam war

World An analysis of health risks in using mobile phones War I. Davidson follows the entire course of the Vietnam War, from the initial French.

A comprehensive analysis of the vietnam war

Appy published this year, is the most piercing and informative work yet on U. Appy is successful in achieving these goals because he examines the U.

He details the lives of American soldiers in Vietnam: He provides a human and realistic account, using personal interviews and rap sessions with scores of veterans. He combines this personal touch with facts, figures and information. But he fails to draw the revolutionary conclusions that flow from this material.

Its central point is that the U. By itself, this is nothing new: But Appy demonstrates how this rule was particularly acute in Vietnam.

Unlike World War II, whose vast scale demanded a mobilization of all social strata, Vietnam was more limited, and the military was determined to channel bourgeois and even middle-class youth away from combat.

This was done through a variety of methods: As well, the middle class was obviously under far less economic compulsion to enlist. Appy estimates that working-class and poor youth composed a full 80 percent of the enlisted ranks.

One might assume that Blacks, getting screwed every other way in this society, would make up a disproportionately high percentage of the war casualties. Actually, Black casualties for the entire war were only slightly disproportionate. However, in the early part of the war, Black casualties were running at nearly twice the rate of white.

Only after intense reaction from the Black movement and the increasing radicalization of Black youth did their percentages drop. Appy also points out that the number of working-class war casualties as a whole inthe year of highest American fatalities, roughly matched the number of American workers who died that year in industrial accidents.

But in Vietnam they faced a mobile guerrilla army with popular support in the countryside. As one highly-decorated machine-gunner summed up the nighttime version of this tactic: We were used as scapegoats to find out where they were.

That was all we were — bait. They knew there was a regiment out there. The general gets another damn medal. A great many casualties were civilians, most of whom died at the hands of American forces. This is not surprising, since, as Appy notes, the thrust of U. Another key point for Appy is countering the notion that the working class was the bastion for pro-war feelings in the country.

Among the informational nuggets: One survey, taken in the same year the media invented the term hard-hatsfound that 48 percent of the northern white working class was in favor of immediate withdrawal of American troops from Vietnam, while only 40 percent of the white middle class took this dove position.

And when the entire working class including Blacks was included, the percentage for withdrawal went up. The working-class youth that volunteered for service did not do so out of any John Wayne-type patriotic fervor.

In fact, a large-scale survey in found the biggest single reason for volunteering was to avoid being drafted! This was even more so when the survey was repeated in Patriotism was the answer of only At the same time, there was a more pronounced opposition among workers to anti-war demonstrators than to the war itself.

Appy is right on the money. This, I think, indicates that working-class anger at the anti-war movement — primarily a middle-class movement — often represented class conflict, not conflict over the legitimacy of the war.

The business people, they run the country and make money from it.Nov 20,  · The Vietnam War () essay. The Vietnam War is considered to be one of the most important events in the history of the United States.

This event influenced the lives of millions of Americans because many citizens of the United States were enrolled in the army.3/5(19). If the Philippine-American War that began in was one of America’s least studied wars, the war in Vietnam that took place over a half century later is surely one of its most studied ones.

The amount of published material on the war in Vietnam is truly amazing, with scores of new books and articles being published every year. Nov 24,  · FRONTLINE's "The Gulf War" is a comprehensive and critical analysis of the war in which more than one million troops faced off against each other in the deserts of the Gulf states.

In America in Vietnam, the first comprehensive revisionist account of the war, political scientist Guenter Lewy contended that the war was winnable if the United States had only prioritized counterinsurgency operations.

Lewy also blamed antiwar activists for creating the myth that the United States was inevitably doomed by the complexities of.

Clockwise, from top a comprehensive analysis of the vietnam war left: World War I. 2 The Vietnam War: A National Dilemma particular course needs.

A comprehensive analysis of the vietnam war

We have not attempted to be comprehensive or prescriptive in our offerings, but rather to give you an array of enticing possibilities for in-depth study, at varying.

Vietnam: the ‘Working-Class War’